VAT and Duties Tribunal 13 August 2004, v 18725 (Roger Barugh v Commissioners of Customs and Excise)

Also known as

United Kingdom · · · 13-08-2004

VAT — ZERO-RATING — construction of wall by non-registered individual claimed to be approved alteration of protected building qualifying for zero-rating — finding that supplies of materials made to appellant’s son — appeal dismissed. VAT — zero-rating — construction of wall —supplier of materials made no supply of services — tax on materials therefore outside terms of recovery in item 2 Group 6 Schedule 8 VATA 1994 MANCHESTER TRIBUNAL CENTRE ROGER BARUGH Appellant - and - THE COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND EXCISE Respondents Tribunal: Mr J D Demack (Chairman) Mr A E Brown FCA Sitting in public in York on 14 July 2004 The Appellant in person Mr Nicholas Mason of Counsel instructed by the Solicitors office of HM Customs and Excise for the Respondents © CROWN COPYRIGHT 2004 DECISION 1. Mr Roger Barugh, the appellant, is a private individual and is not registered for VAT. He claims to be entitled to repayment of VAT totalling £1,073.04 paid on the supply of materials in the form of bricks, capping stones and iron railings used to build a wall within the curtilage of his dwellinghouse - a listed building. The wall in question is not attached to the dwelling. 2. Mr Mark Barugh, the appellant’s son, made the claim pursued by his father by letter of 30 September 2003. The Commissioners of Customs and Excise rejected it on 3 October 2003 for the following reasons: “ 1) the wall is not attached to the dwelling, and, is not within the provisions for relief from VAT; and 2) the materials were supplied, but not fitted, by the suppliers: they were supplied to Mark Barugh for private use, and thus the VAT charged could not be reclaimed. “ 3) We pointed out to Mr Roger Barugh that the invoices on which his claim was based were all addressed to his son, and not to him. He confirmed that his son had bought the materials in question and had paid for them. Mr Barugh claimed that his son had acted as his agent in the purchases, but adduced no evidence in support.

Read the full text

This document is published by caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.