The Supreme Court 2 May 2012, [2012] UKSC 17 (Petroleo Brasileiro SA v E.N.E. Kos 1 Limited)
Also known as
United Kingdom · · · Cited by 17 · 02-05-2012
Easter Term [2012] UKSC 17 On appeal from: [2010] EWCA Civ 772 JUDGMENT Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. ( Respondent ) v E.N.E. Kos 1 Limited ( Appellant ) before Lord Phillips, President Lord Walker Lord Mance Lord Clarke Lord Sumption JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 2 May 2012 Heard on 12 January 2012 Appellant Respondent Timothy Brenton QC Andrew Baker QC Henry Byam-Cook (Instructed by Ince & Co LLP) (Instructed by Thomas Cooper Solicitors) LORD SUMPTION: (with whom Lord Walker agrees) 1. This appeal is about the rights of the owner of a time-chartered ship after the ship has been lawfully withdrawn for non-payment of hire. The question must often have arisen in practice but, oddly enough, there is no direct authority upon it. 2. The MT Kos is a 301,000 mt VLCC. She was time chartered by her owners to Petroleo Brasileiro SA on 2 June 2006 for 36 months plus or minus 15 days at charterers’ option. The charterparty, which was on the Shelltime 3 Form, contained a standard form of withdrawal clause providing that if hire was not paid when due, the owners should have the right to withdraw the vessel “without prejudice to any claim owners may otherwise have on charterers under this charter.” It is increasingly common for such contracts to include anti-technicality clauses requiring notice to be given before this right is exercised. But for whatever reason no anti-technicality clause was included in this case. So when, on 31 May 2008, charterers failed to make the advance payment required for the month of June, the owners were entitled to withdraw the MT Kos , and did so at 14.41 GMT on 2 June 2008. It is agreed between the parties to the appeal that the charterers’ failure to pay hire was not a repudiatory breach of contract. 3. At the time of the withdrawal, the MT Kos was at Angra dos Reis in Brazil, where she had just completed the loading of a parcel of cargo for the charterers’ account in accordance with their orders.
Read the full text
This document is published by caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk.
Moonlit adds the citation network (17 references), article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit