Supreme Court of the United Kingdom 24 April 2013, [2013] UKSC 21 (Uprichard v Scottish Ministers and another (Scotland))

Easter Term [2013] UKSC 21 On appeal from: [2011] CSIH 77 JUDGMENT Uprichard (Appellant) v Scottish Ministers and another (Respondents) (Scotland) before Lord Hope, Deputy President Lord Kerr Lord Reed Lord Carnwath Lord Carloway JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 24 April 2013 Heard on 5 and 6 March 2013 Appellant Respondent James Findlay QC Ruth Crawford QC Stephen O'Rourke Alistair Duncan QC (Instructed by