Supreme Court of the United States April 1, 1800 (O'HARRA v. Hall)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-1800

4 U.S. 340 (____) 4 Dall. 340 O'Harra versus Hall. Supreme Court of United States. CHASE, Justice. You may explain, but you cannot alter, a written contract, by parol testimony. A case of explanation, implies uncertainty, ambiguity, and doubt, upon the face of the writing. But the proposition now, is a plain case of alteration: that is, an offer to prove by witnesses, that the assignor promised something, beyond the plain words and meaning of his written contract. Such evidence is inadmissible; and has been so adjudged by the Supreme Court, in Clarke v. Russel, 3 Dall. Rep. 415. As to the authority of Moscs v. M`Farlan, it has always been suspected, and has lately been over-ruled, on the principle, *341 that the previous decision, ther brought into question, was pronounced by a competent Court. I grant, that chancery will not confine itself to the strict rule, in cases of fraud, and of trust. But we are sitting as Judges at common-law; and I can perceive no reason to depart from it. PETERS, Justice. If we were sitting as Judges in a state Court, I should be inclined to admit the testimony, in order to attain the real justice of the cause; as there is no Court of equity in Pennsylvania. But there is no such defect in the federal jurisdiction; and, therefore, when the party comes to the common law side of the Court, he must be content with the strict common law rule of evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.