Court of Appeals of Virginia October 23, 1802 (Elliott's v. Lyell)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1802

ROANE, Judge.

This is an action of debt, against the executors of Richard Elliott, on a joint bond entered into by the said Richard Elliott, with T. Butler and W. Walker, on the 17th of October, 1782. At the trial, the plaintiff having offered the bond in evidence to support his action, the defendant objected thereto, and applied to the Court to instruct the jury, “Whether the action against the defendant, as executor of Richard Elliott, is maintainable, or not ?” But the Court being of opinion, that, as the obligor Richard Elliott died since the commencement of the act concerning joint rights and obligations, hiu representatives arc made chargeable by that act, upon the said obligation, in the same manner, as if it had been several as well- as joint, refused to instruct the jury, to the effect desired by the defendant.

The rectitude of this opinion, is now to be considered:

The question here, is not, whether the Legislature have power to pass a retrospective law, if it thinks proper ? *242But, whether the general words of the act in question, shall he construed to have a retrospective operation ?

Nor is the question here, whether the Legislature has power to transfer to a Court of Common Law, cognizance of a claim, which would, evidently, be established in a Court of Equity ? There is nothing in this record, as it now stands, which would justify a Court of Equity in decreeing the money against the representatives of Richard Elliott, on the ground of a moral obligation in him paramount to the bond; there is nothing which evidently shews, that he was the real principal, or received the benefit for which the bond was given: Whatever our conjectures may be on this point, the record does not bear us out on this occasion: And it was well observed by Mr. Hay, on the former argument, that for any thing known to us, it might have been a joint debt, due for a joint benefit, received by all the obligors.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.