New York Supreme Court November 15, 1806 (Tillotson v. Cheetham)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1806
Kent, Ch. J.
delivered the opinion of the court.
The first question arising upon this motion is, whether the writ of inquiry was well executed before the deputy sheriff.
This appeared to me upon the argument to be a novel objection ; for it has been usual to execute writs of inquiry before the deputy, with as little hesitation as before the sheriff. It has been taught us by the best books of practice, that the form of a ticket to. a witness, subpeenaed before a jury of inquiry, is to appear before the sheriff or under sheriff. (Rich. C. B. practice, vol. 1. 149.) The cases of Ketle v. Bromsell, Wallace v. Humes, Davis v. Skillins, and Dixon v. Goodman, (Barnes, p. p. 230, 231, 232, and 431.) and the case of Denny v. Trapnell, (3 Wils. 378.) are sufficient to place the modern practice and its sanction by the court of C. B. beyond all doubt or contradiction. The counsel for thé defendant was not however satisfied with the authority of the practical cases in Barnes; yet those cases are at least'conclusive, as historical evidence, to prove the fact that deputjr sheriffs in England, during the reign of George II. did execute writs of inquiry, and that no question was máde as to its legality. The case in Wilson is as late as the year 1768, and is a correct and high authority; that case con*70iains the admission of the counsel on each side, that the practice of the court of K. B. was in this particular the same. But some older cases have been alluded to, as intimating a contrary doctrine; and it was said that the execution of a writ of inquiry was a judicial act, which cannot be delegated. It may therefore be satisfactory to the parties to go further into the subject, and to look more attentively into the foundations upon which our present practice is supported.
The deputy is an officer coeval in point of antiquity with the sheriff, and is recognised in the most ancient statutes. (W. 2. 13 E. 1. c. 39.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit