Supreme Court of Pennsylvania June 13, 1812 (White v. Lessee of Kyle)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-06-1812
Tilghman C. J.
On the trial of this ejectment, the opinion of the Court of Common Pleas was asked on seven points' on the part of the defendant, who is plaintiff in error in ’this court. But our decision is requested on only two of those points, viz. the 1st and 5th.
The 1st question is whether any title, legal or equitable, could be acquired by a settlement made on lands before they were purchased by the late proprietaries from the Indians, without a special promise from the proprietaries to the settler. The opinion of the court below was that an equitable title might be acquired.
This is a question of very easy solution. It was the uniform custom of the late proprietaries, not to exercise any act of ownership in the soil contained in their charter limits, before they had come to an agreement with the natives. They made no surveys on the unpurchased lands, either for themselves or others, without the consent of the natives; and this policy, founded on the plainest principles of justice and good sense, was adopted by the legislature. So early as the year 1700, an act of assembly was passed, declaring void all purchases of land made by private persons from the Indians, without permission of the proprietary. It appears that great discontent prevailed among the Indians at the intrusion by the white people on the very lands now in dispute. So much so, that in order to appease them, Richard Peters, then secretary of the land office, went with some magistrates, for the express purpose of removing the settlers, and they were removed, and their houses burnt. But in order to conduct tiie matter as speedily and'with as little disturbance as possible, Mr. Peters promised some of the setters, particularly William White, deceased, under whom the defendants claim, who had great influence, that ’if they would remove quietly, their lands should be granted to them after the proprietary should purchase them of the Indians.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit