New York Court of Chancery June 22, 1815 (Denton v. Denton)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-06-1815

The Chancellor.

As the application for a ne exeat is ex parte, and as the wife is permitted to sue her husband in this court, her affidavit, as plaintiff, is admissible, on the same ground as that of any other plaintiff; and process of injunction, and a ne exeat, are, according to the usual course and practice of the court, obtained on the oath of the party. The case of Sedgwick v. Watkins does not appear to be founded on just principles. For the purpose of carrying on this suit, the wife is considered as independent of her husband, and she ought to be permitted to enjoy the rights of a party. In the case of Shaftoe v. Shaftoe, (7 Ves. 171.,) the application, for a ne exeat was made on the oath of the wife, and no objection was taken ; and the Lord Chancellor proceeded to consider the merits of the motion, on the strength of her affidavit. The case in 1 Vesey, is, therefore, to be considered as virtually overruled. The case of Shaftoe v. Shaftoe is analogous in another respect, as the motion for a ne exeat was there made prior to any decree of alimony, *443and was founded on the information and belief of the wife.

The great difficulty in these applications, when a suit is pending for alimony, is, that the right to alimony, and the amount of it, is uncertain ; and there is no certain sum for which to mark the writ. This court has always expressed an inclination to interfere in favour of the wife, if that difficulty could be surmounted. Lord Loughborough said he would grant the writ, if he could find a precedent; and Lord Hardwicke said, the we exeat had been granted in this single case of alimony, out of compassion to the wife. (7 Ves. 173, Dawson v. Dawson, 1 Ves. jun, 94, Coglar v. Coglar, 2 Atk. 210. Anon. Haffey v. Haffey, 14 Ves. 261.) It does not appear to me that the difficulty of fixing on a sum is, absolutely, insurmountable. Courts of law always surmount it, when the writ is marked for bail in actions founded on torts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.