Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1815 (Parker v. Lincoln)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1815

Jackson, J.

It is not doubted that an infant be a mort gagee at common law ; and there is nothing in our statutes *or usages to make it otherwise here. Whether he is the [*18] original grantee, or takes the estate by descent, he is bound by the conditions contained in the conveyance. The mortgage deed must be good in the whole, or void in the whole.

If Trott, the minor, had not had a guardian, he might have been made the sole defendant in this bill, and the Court would appoint him a guardian for this cause. It is still necessary to appoint such a guardian, notwithstanding Lincoln, his legal guardian, is made a defendant. For the latter is not, strictly speaking, sued as guardian , and, if he had had no personal concern in the transactions in question, *24he need not, and perhaps ought not, to have been included as a defendant in this bill.(1)

But here, Lincoln, the .guardian, is, or at least may be, personally concerned in the event of this suit. One object of the bill is, to ascertain whether he has received any thing, and how much, on account of the debt due to the minor, either from the original debtor, or from the rents and profits of the mortgaged premises. If he had not been made a party, the Court must still have determined what sums he had so received ; and the amount thus ascertained would have been deducted from the sum now due to Trott on the bond. But Lincoln, not being a party, would not be concluded by that decree ; and, in an after settlement between him and his ward, he might undertake to show that he had not réceived so much. This would expose the minor to an inconvenience and hazard, to which he ought not to be subjected.

It is one of the peculiar advantages of chancery jurisdiction, that the Court can bring before them.at once all persons having any interest or concern in the subject in controversy ; .and it is always a valid objection to a bill, if it does not make every such person a party in the suit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.