Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1815 (Baker v. Mair)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1815
Thatcher, J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court.
* As this action is brought for the use of Darling, and [*123] there being no question as to the assignment, or the notice thereof to the defendant, there can be no doubt that any acts, which would have been previously necessary to be done by the plaintiff, to entitle him to recover for himself had there been no assignment, will avail now in this action, although done by Darling.
The first inquiry is, What is the real meaning of the contract, or wf it are the rights and duties of the parties under it ? And, secondly, What effect has the proposition made by Darling to the defendant, just before the expiration of the twenty days, if assented to by the latter, upon the contract ? and, thirdly, upon the supposition that the proposition made by Darling was not assented to by the defendant ?
Though the contract seems to be made up of parts of a note, put together a little out of the usual-arrangement of such instruments, this is easily accounted for by adverting to the particular manner in which it was probably drawn up ; nor does it at all perplex its import, which is clearly intended to allow the defendant twenty days to prepare himself to perform the work mentioned in it, after he should be first called upon to do it; although it might not have been so intended when the first part of the note or contract was written. There seems to be no doubt, in my mind, that the note in question was written to the word ‘‘demand,” and calculated by .the writer, or the plaintiff, to be the whole contract, and was, in that state, handed to the defendant to subscribe. But on reading it he observed, that he could not agree to its terms ; that he had frequent engagements, which would interfere with his performance of this, unless he could have some previous notice, which would enable him to prepare for its fulfilment. Upon this the plaintiff probably wrote the provision contained in the contract for twenty days’ notice.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit