Supreme Court of Louisiana December 15, 1815 (Bayon v. Prevot)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1815

Martin, J.

delivered the opinion of the court. The plaintiffs’ counsel contends that he has shewn that the tobacco was their property, that Allen, Stockton & co. were their agents and consigned it to the defendants, restricting them to sell it at twelve cents and a half per pound, and that as they sold it for ten cents, the plaintiffs have lost two cents and a half per pound, which it is the object of the present suit to recover.

*67As no specific cause of action was alledged in the petition, other than the non payment of an undescript claim, the evidence ought, at least, to have established the plaintiffs’ right to a recovery, the general issue having been pleaded. That the plaintiffs were, in any manner interested in this shipment of tobacco, we are left to presume from the circumstance of Sterling Allen having, as their agents, made the necessary affidavit, in order to procure the writ of attachment. The conclusion is far from being strictly logical. He might have become their agent since the cause of action arose: even for the sole purpose of instituting the suit. Admitting him, however, to have been the plaintiffs’ agent ab initio, does it follow as a necessary consequence that every transaction and consignment of his is for the account of these, his principals? Are also all the transactions and consignments of Stockton, Allen & co. for the account of the plaintiffs? If they be not, how is this consignment of tobacco to be distinguished from the rest?

But admitting all these queries to be properly answered in the affirmative, it is far from being clear that the defendants have been guilty of any deviation from the orders of the consignees. These gentlemen gave no positive instructions, except that the sale of the tobacco should not be *68delayed, if twelve cents and a half could be obtained on its arrival.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.