Supreme Court of Pennsylvania April 15, 1815 (Irving v. Taggart)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1815
Tilghman C. J.
A motion has been made to take off the nonsuit, on two grounds ; — 1st. Because the judge was mistaken in his opinion, that probable cause had been shewn. 2d. Because a nonsuit ought not to have been entered against the plaintiff’s consent. If the plaintiff succeeds in establishing either of these grounds, the nonsuit must be taken off. I shall confine my opinion to the latter. Although I know of no solemn decision of this court expressly on the point, yet I have always considered it as settled, that a nonsuit could not be entered, if the- plaintiff insisted upon answering; and this opinion has been expressed by me upon several occasions. That such has been the practice, I believe I may safely venture to affirm ; so that the only consideration, at present, will be, whether there be any reason for altering that practice ? The form of recording a nonsuit, is, that the plaintiff, although solemnly called, did not appear. But when he an*361sw'ers, he does appeal'. It is false, therefore, to say that he did not appear, when he answered. Suppose then the plaintiff answers, what course is the judge to take? He cannot order the clerk to record a non-appearance, in the face of the truth. Can he forbid the plaintiff to answer, on pain of being considered in contempt ? I have met with no authority, before the revolution, extending the power of the court so far. It certainly was not carried to that extent in England, nor do I believe that it is even at this day. The very case occurred before the late Judge Buller, than whom there was no greater lawyer in his time. He was of opinion, that the plaintiff had failed in supporting his action, and therefore directed a nonsuit; but when the plaintiff was called, he answered. The learned judge did not, upon this, insist on the nonsuit, but directed the jury to find for the defendant.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit