Supreme Court of Pennsylvania May 24, 1815 (Christ v. Diffenbach)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-1815

Tilghman C. J.

John Christ (the plaintiff in error) rented a mill and land of the defendants in error. The lease was in writing; and the question is, whether the parol evidence mentioned in the bill of exceptions, was receivable ? I am not for carrying parol evidence farther than is warranted by decisions which are binding on this court; but it is too late, now, to consider, whether more good or harm has resulted from the admission of such evidence, in any case of writing. Without citing cases, or undertaking to enumerate all the exceptions -to the general rule, it may be laid down as settled law, that parol evidence is admissible in cases of fraud, and of plain mistake in drawing a writing. The evidence offered in the present case went directly to establish a fraud. A certain rent had been agreed upon between the lessors and lessee, on an understanding that the lessors were to widen and deepen the tail race of the mill, at their own expense. While the writings were drawing, the parties went to view the mill. When they came back, and were about to execute them, the lessee perceived that the clause respecting the tail race was omitted. He objected to signing, but was induced to it, by the lessors’ promise that they would do what had been agreed upon, in the months of June, July, or August next ensuing. Trusting to this, he executed the lease, and now the lessors say, that they find nothing of the tail race in the writing, and to that only they look. 1'his is the case which the plaintiff offered to prove, and, if established, was he not tricked into *466the execution of the lease ? Or would such conduct be any thing' more or less than a downright fraud, on the part of the defendants ? Whether the plaintiff could have made good his assertion, is not now to be inquired of; but, undoubtedly, he should have been allowed an opportunity of doing it. I am, therefore, of opinion, that the judgment should be reversed, and a venire facias de novo awarded.

Ye ates J.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.