Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 30, 1815 (American Fire Insurance v. Pringle)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-12-1815
Tilghman C. J.
This case arises on the «. Act securing : “ to mechanics and others payment for their labour and ma- “ terials, in erecting any house or other building within the “ city and county of Philadelphia.” The facts reported to the Court are, that John Mullo-wny commenced the building of a house and sold it before it was finished to John Print gle, who went on with the building after his purchase. Mulloxvny conveyed the house to Pringle on the 15th November, 1813, and on the same day took a mortgage, as security for the purchase money, which was immediately recorded. The question is, whether this mortgage shall be preferred to the debts of the workmen and persons who furnished materials for going on with the building, after the recording of the mortgage. The act of assembly gives a lien to the workmen and persons who furnished materials, to be preferred to any other liem -which originated subsequent to the commencement of the house or other building.
The case falls clearly within the words of the law, because the mortgage was subsequent to the commencement of the building. But it is contended, on the part of the plaintiffs, assignees of the mortgage, that it is not within the spirit of the law, because the debts of those persons who now claim a preference, were contracted after the mortgage was upon record. They suppose, that there is a great difference between ak house begun and finished by the same person, and begun by one person and finished by another. To be sure, if the house had been begun and finished by the same person, there could have been no question; but I do not see why the workmen, &c. should lose their lien, because it was finished by a different person from him who began it. The house is what they look to for their security, and the law tells them *139that no other lien originating after the commencement of the house, shall come in competition with them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit