U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1815 (Thompson v. Faussat)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1815

■WASHINGTON, Circuit Justice.

The principle contended for by the appellants’ counsel, that a receipt in full of all demands, is not conclusive, against the giver of it, is. as a general principle, unquestionably correct. It is so settled in the English and American courts. Like a settled account, it is only prima facie evidence of what it purports to be, upon the face of it; and upon satisfactory proof being made, that it was obtained by fraud, or was given under a mistake, either of facts, or under an ignorance of the legal rights of the party who gave it; it may be inquired into and corrected in a court of law, as well as in a court of equity. When this is made out by evidence, it then appears, that beyond the sum actually paid, it was given without consideration. But this .want of consideration, ought to be made clearly to appear by the party who attempts to impeach the validity of the instrument. If this is not done, the presumption in fa-vour of the written acknowledgment of the party, must prevail. An agreement for instance, made for the purpose of settling family differences, will not be set aside even in equity, though it were founded on mistake. In like manner, 1 conceive, if the legal rights of the party who gives the receipt, be doubtful, and are honestly contested by the other side; and time and opportunity are afforded him to satisfy himself upon the matter in dispute, and he finally agrees to compromise, and to accept less that he might in strictness be entitled to; the court will hold him bound.

As to the point of law. arising in this case, in relation to the wages, which these seamen had a right to claim; it appears to be quite unsettled. I have met with no case, which precisely resembles it, in any book of reports; nor with any principle in the ordinances, or usages of other nations, which strictly applies to it. In the cases cited from 12 Mod. 409, and Ld. Raym.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.