U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1815 (Willings v. Consequa)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1815
WASHINGTON, Circuit Justice.
The contracts upon which these suits are brought, have been fully proved; that they have not been fulfilled by Consequa, can hardly be denied. As to the cargo of the Asia, in addition to the acknowledgment of Consequa, that it was not of good quality; it was examined thoroughly, at Philadelphia, by unexceptionable judges, who have stated to you its quality and relative value, to other teas, then in market. As to the cargoes of the Bingham and Ganges, sold at Amsterdam by the Asiatic Company, at their public sales; it cannot be denied, that the prices at which those teas were sold, compared with the prices of other cargoes of good quality, sold at the same periods; furnish, at least, some evidence of their quality. It appears, that from the time of the arrival of a cargo of tea, in the Texel, it is taken under the care of the East India Company; is kept in their warehouses; samples of each chest are taken out and examined, and finally that those sales are attended by merchants, from different parts of Europe, amongst whom there are no doubt many competent judges of the article sold. It would seem reasonable therefore to conclude, generally, that the prices bid at those sales, for different parcels of teas of the same denomination, must bear some proportion to their quality; and consequently afford some evidence of that fact. In addition to this evidence, the jury have the testimony of a distinguished tea broker, who speaks very unfavourably of those teas, and considers them to be only of second or third quality.
But, although sales at auction may, in general, afford some evidence of the comparative value of the article sold, still as a standard of quality, they may not always be satisfactory, much less conclusive. The prices bid, may frequently depend upon the state of the market, or the age of the teas, either positively or relatively, to other teas, sold at the same time, of superior quality and. fresher.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit