Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court March 15, 1817 (Codman v. Jenkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1817

Wilde, J.

The estate, for the use and occupation of which this action is brought, having been demised by one John Austin to the defendant, to hold during the life of the lessor, at the yearly rent of twenty dollars, and the reversion having been afterwards conveyed to the plaintiffs, it has been argued that they have a right to recover the rent, as incident to the reversion, in this form of action.

It is, however, a well-settled principle, that an action of assumpsit for use and occupation will not lie where rent is reserved by deed; the proper action, in such case, being debt or covenant. It is, in deed, said, in some of the books, that assumpsit may be maintained upon an express promise ; although the plaintiff may be entitled to *86a remedy of a higher nature, as debt or covenant. But the better opinion seems to be, that this principle must be limited to cases where some new consideration forms the basis of the promise, as where there is a promise to pay the balance due on settlement of an account, including rent in arrear;‘ or where other matter is taken into consideration, and included with the rent. (6)

In conformity to this principle, the statute of 11 Geo. 2, c. 19, <§>14, which provides a remedy for the recovery of rent, by action of assumpsit for use and occupation, limits it to cases where the agreement is not by deed. Nor is it easy to discern any good reason why it should not be thus limited; since, where the * demise is by deed, another remedy is provided, applicable to the contract.

If the plaintiffs therefore would claim the rent in arrear, under the assignment of the reversion by John Austin, it must be recovered in an action of debt or covenant; provided the lease were by deed, as we understand the fact to have been, although it is not so expressly stated by the parties.

We will now consider whether the plaintiffs can maintain their action as heirs at law of Anne Austin.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.