Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court September 15, 1817 (Saxton v. Nimms)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1817

Parker, C. J.

The statute which authorizes the raising and assessing taxes in school districts, having required that the meetings for such purposes shall be warned at least seven days before they are held, and that any vote to raise money, for the purpose of erecting or repairing a school-house, passed by a majority of the inhabitants present at a district meeting warned and held as aforesaid, shall be obligatory on the inhabitants, to be assessed, levied, and collected, as prescribed in the act, it would seem to follow, as the manifest intent of the legislature, that any vote to raise money, at a meeting otherwise warned and held, should not be obligatory.

If, then, it appeared, by legal evidence, in the case before us, that the meeting at which the money was raised, for his proportion of which the plaintiff was assessed, and his property distrained, was warned less than seven days before the meeting was held, the vote and all the subsequent proceedings would be void, and the defendants would be trespassers, for having authorized an unlawful seizure of the plaintiff’s property. By the return of the person to whom the warrant for calling the meeting was directed, it appears that full seven days’ warning was given ; but by the evidence at the trial it was satisfactorily proved to the jury that some of the inhabitants of the district had less than seven days’ notice.

The case, then, turns altogether upon the competency of the evidence given to impeach the return upon the warrant. And in this case against the assessors, acting compulsorily under the law, which requires them to assess such taxes as shall be voted, we think such evidence ought not to have been admitted. They have a right to presume that the meeting at which the money was raised was lawfully warned; for by the records it appeared to be so. They could not otherwise call the fact in question, than by examining witnesses #as to the truth of the return, which they were under no obligation to do.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.