Supreme Court of Louisiana March 15, 1817 (Meeker's Assignees v. Williamson)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1817
Derbigny, J.
delivered the opinion of the court. The first step, in the investigation of this cause, is to ascertain the nature of the action.—The petition states that the plaintiffs, being owners of a certain house, agreed with Williamson, one of the bankrupts, whose rights are here represented by the defendants, that he should occupy it as their tenant; that Williamson, not having paid them any rent for it, was required to quit the premises, but refused so to do. It concludes by praying that Williamson may be decreed to deliver up the possession of the house and pay damages for the detention. The present defendants in their answer deny these facts and dispute the validity of the plaintiffs’ title.
It is insisted by the plaintiffs that this is a possessory action, and that they have a right to be restored to their possession, independently of any inquiry into their title: but, as they have adduced no other proof of that possession, than a bill of sale of the premises to them, it is impossible to pronounce on the question of possession, *626without examining whether the bill of sale, be such as they could possess under.
In mere actions recuperandæ possessionis the fact of possession alone is at issue. The plaintiff, proving that he was in possession, and ousted by violence, fraud or artifice, becomes entitled to recover possession at once: the other party, not being even permitted to say that the plaintiff has no title to the thing. But when the plaintiff puts at issue his right of possessing, as where he alleges that he is the owner, and presents his title, as the evidence of his possession, the simple fact of possessing is no longer the only question. The defendant is then allowed to dispute the validity of that title, and is maintained in the actual enjoyment of the premises, if the plaintiff fails to make his title good. Greg. Lopez on Part. 3, 2, 7, and Gomez in leg. Tauri 45, n. 118.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit