Supreme Court of Louisiana March 15, 1817 (Clague v. Lewis)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-03-1817
Martin, J.
delivered the opinion of the court. Lewis, a partner of Lee, in his absence, obtained a meeting of the creditors of the firm, to deliberate on its affairs. Previous to the meeting, some of the creditors suggested their apprehension of his withdrawing with the effects of the firm and held him to security: at the same time the court appointed provisional syndics.
At the meeting, he made a cession of the goods of the firm and prayed for his discharge. A great majority of the creditors, both in number and amount, refused to accept the cession and to grant a discharge.
He prayed for the homologation of the proceedings, and a great number of the creditors joined in a suggestion of fraud and opposed the homologation. A jury was empannelled to try the question of fraud: they could not agree and were discharged by consent. Lewis then prayed and had leave to discontinue his suit. The creditors, several weeks after, prayed for the reinstating of the suit, which the judge declined. They appealed from the judgment of discontinuance.
*674The whole record is brought up and Lewis insists on his right to discontinue. His counsel relies on Partida 5, 15, 2. 4 Febrero juicios, 25.ff de cessione bonorum 42, 3. Curia Philipica 198, 19, Partida 6, 2 29.
The fifth partida provides that if a ceding creditor says that he wishes to recover his goods, before they are sold, and pay his creditors or contest their claims, they are not to be sold and he is to be heard.
This does not establish clearly any right in him to withdraw his suit and resume his goods: on the contrary it implies that the suit ought to he continued, since he is to be heard. The authority seems to provide for the suspension of the sale, till the judgment pronounces on his application, which consequently cannot be considered as a matter of absolute right.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit