Supreme Court of Louisiana July 15, 1817 (Broutin v. Vassant)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-07-1817
Mathews, J.
delivered the opinion of the court. Considering, as we do, the formalities prescribed by law, for testaments to be of such solemnity and substance, that they must punctually and entirely be fulfilled, we are of opin- ion that the will, under consideration, cannot be supported as a mystic one: although it was closed, sealed and delivered to the notary, in presence of a sufficient number of witnesses, and the act of superscription drawn up by him, (in a style, indeed, confuse and indefinite, but perhaps sufficiently intelligible, to give validity to the instrument, were it perfect in other re-spects,) is defficient in a material formality; the testatrix not having declared, at the time of handing the will to the notary, whether it was written by herself, or by another by her direc- tions, and whether she signed it or not. This is a defect, which destroys the validity of the East'n District *183will, as a mystic one. It remains to be examined, whether it be valid as an olographic will.
The question, whether a will which, on account of informality in its execution, is void in the form intended to be used by the testator, can and ought to be supported in another, provided it be clothed with all the requisite formalities, seems, from the authorities produced, to have been agitated in France, before the introduction of the Napoleon code. In its solution, a contrariety is found, both in the determination of courts of justice, and in the opinions of jurists. Under the operation of the code, this question, although raised in several instances, does not appear to have been formally decided.
Merlin, inhis Collection de questions de droit, in the case of a contested will, discusses extensively the question now under considera- tion-Whether a mystic will, not valid on ac- count of imperfections in the act of superscrip- tion, can be valid as an olographic will, when wholly written, dated and subscribed, in the handwriting of the testator?
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit