General Court of Virginia November 15, 1817 (Warner v. Commonwealth)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1817
White, J.,
prepared the following opinion :
After stating the Case, and the questions arising from the verdict, he says, Before I go into the merits of the Case propounded by the jury, I would observe, 1st, (and that not for the sake of this Case, but to prevent any misunderstanding with respect to Cases which may hereafter arise,) that, without supposing the Common Law to be in force in Pennsylvania, of which, perhaps, it may be said, the Court in this Case have no Judicial knowledge, it appears by the Marriage Act of that State, as found by the jury, that marriages may in certain cases take place there lawfully, without the presence of a Justice of the Peace, (a) And, therefore, it cannot be admitted as a general principle, that in a prosecution of this kind, founded on a first marriage charged to have been made in Pennsylvania, it is always necessary to prove that a Justice of the Peace -was present. It is readily admitted, that in this Case, the marriage attempted to be proved, was solemnized under the general *provision of the Act found by the jury, requiring marriages to be solemnized'by the parties taking each other tobe husband and wife, in the presence of twelve witnesses, one of whom, it appears by a subsequent part of the same Act, ought to be a “ Justice of the Peace and that the jury intended, that this question should and ought to be decided under a due construction of that provision. The observation is made merely to confine the decision in this case to that part of the said Act, to which it properly belongs. 2. This supposed marriage is alleged to be without the State of Virginia, and within the State of Pennsylvania ; the Laws of which latter State, are foreign to our Courts, and are as far from being judicially known to them, until properly proved, as the Laws of Prance or Spain. It is true, the Constitution of the United States has provided a mode of proving those Laws to our Courts different from that in which other foreign Laws are proved.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit