Supreme Court of Connecticut June 15, 1818 (Beers v. Hawley)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1818

Swift, Cb, J,

In this case, the plaintiffs, as grantees of Minor, claimed a priority of title, on the ground, that hi; deed was first recorded. Wright, one of the defendants,, claimed an equality of title, and that he was tenant in common with Minor, on the ground, that the execution of the *469deeds was simultaneous, and that his deed was recorded in a reasonable and proper time : and, to prove the fact, offered the written declaration of Minor, when he was the owner of the land, and in possession ; which w as rejected by the court.

It is generally true, that the deed which is first recorded shall prevail; but to this there are exceptions. Where the second grantee, having notice of the existence of a prior deed procures his deed to be first recorded, it shall not prevail against; such prior deed. Where the first grantee procures his deed to be recorded within a reasonable and proper time after its execution, it will be valid against a subsequent deed, though first recorded j for every purchaser is entitled to a reasonable time to procure his deed to be recorded. Both these deeds bear date, and were recorded, on the same day ; but the deed to Minor was received for record, about five minutes before the deed to Wright. As both deeds were recorded in a reasonable time, it becomes material to ascertain the time of their execution : for if their execution was simultaneous, Minor and Wright, by operation of law, became tenants ip common.

The time of the execution and delivery of a deed is always a matter in pais, to be proved like any other fact; and it is competent for the party to shew a delivery on a day different from the date. His confession, admission, or dec. larat.ion, whether by parol or in writing, (while interested and in possession,) against his interest, is proper evidence, notwithstanding a subsequent conveyance; subject, however, to be explained, like any other testimony.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.