Supreme Court of Louisiana September 15, 1820 (Muse v. Curtis)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1820
Martin, J.
delivered the opinion of the court. The plaintiff, in this case, had a verdict and judgment—the defendant, on an appeal obtained a rev*83ersal of the judgment, on the ground that it contained the citation of no law, nor any of the reasons on which it was grounded, 5 Martin, 686. Whereupon the case was remanded, with directions to the district judge, to proceed and give judgment, according to the directions of the constitution and law. He did so, in favour of the plaintiff, and the defendant appealed.
West'n District.
September, 1820.
His counsel assigns as an error, apparent on the record, that the judgment was given at November term, on a verdict rendered in June preceding, without any new proceedings thereon : whereas, it is contended, a trial de novo ought to have taken place, on the return of the case into the district court.
It is urged that a reversal, like an arrest, of judgment, avoids the verdict, on which it was rendered. We do not think so.
A judgment is arrested, when it appears that the record is so imperfect, that no judgment can be rendered thereon. It is, therefore, clear that, in such a case, the verdict can be of no avail—for it finds facts, on which no judgment can be given. The defect is in some thing anterior to the verdict, and sublato fundamento, cadit opus. When, on the contrary, the defect is some thing posterior, the verdict is not affected thereby, and nothing prevents its being proceeded on after the reversal of the judg*84ment, if there be no defect in the proceedings anterior to the verdict.
The counsel further relies on a provision of the court law, 2 Martin's Dig. 193, n. 14, which requires that the district judge should render their judgments, in the shortest possible delay, and they should never leave in suspense any decision in cases tried, when they close a session of their respective courts.
In the present case, the letter of the law has been complied with.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit