Supreme Court of Alabama December 15, 1822 (Brahan v. Ragland)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1822

Judge Lipscomb

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The only point here presented for consideration is, whether the Jury or the Court should determine on the reasonableness of notice to charge the indorser. In the English Courts, from the time of Lord Mansfield, it has been considered a mixed question. The Jury inquired if notice had been given and when — the Court then determined on its reasonableness. In the case of Tindal against Brown (1 Term, 168,) Lord Mansfield, after laying it down to be a mixed question of law and fact, said, That whenever a rule could possibly be laid down, the reasonableness of notice should be decided by the, Court. All the English decisions follow the same rule. In Ireland against Rip (11 Johnson, 232,) Judge Spencer, after recognizing the principle of the English decisions and insisting on the necessity of certainty and uniformity in commercial transactions, says, decisions of other Courts in other countries on such points are entitled ■to little consideration. The great extent and population of London and its neighbourhood might well admit of a rule like the one in the case cited, (Scott and al. against Clifford) while such a rule here would be inapplicable and iinproper. The learned Judge then proceeds to lay down the rule in New-York, bottomed on their customs and peculiar situation.

The positions which I think fairly to be deduced from these authorities are, 1st, That if commercial regulations have settled down to fixed customs, those customs become the law which must govern the Jury. 2d, That these customs are not uniform in the commercial world, but in different countries different customs prevail. 3d, That in the absence of such customs the Jury must, from the necessi*87ty of the case, determine on the reasonableness of the notice.

The first position is so fully supported by the authorities quoted, that it does not require the aid of argument. The second can be as fairly sustained by adjudged cases and by common sense.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.