Court for the Trial of Impeachments and Correction of Errors December 15, 1823 (James v. Morey)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1823

Woodworth, J.

On the 17th June, 1817, Caleb Johnson gave a mortgage to James O. Wattles, to secure the payment of $12,000. On the 2d August, 1817, a judgment was docketted in favor of Wattles against Johnson for $2000. Executions issued on this, and three other judgments, (all subsequent to the mortgage,) and on the 20th April, 1818, the mortgaged premises were sold in separate parcels. William H. Sabin purchased the first .parcel for $205, which, at the time of sale, was worth $2000. Wattles purchased the residue at $440.

The facts stated.

The value of the mortgaged premises appears to have • been somewhere between $6000 and $10,000. Deeds were executed by the Sheriff to the purchasers.

Reuben West testified, that before the close of the sale, he heard Wattles publicly say, he had a mortgage on the pro perty, executed by Johnson.

Several other witnesses testify, that they were present, and heard no claim set up under the mortgage. It is in proof, that before the sale, Wattles at different times, stated that Johnson had given a quit claim deed of the premises. This evidence, however, is insufficient to establish a release: *283it was so considered by the Chancellor, and was not pressed on the argument. After the sale, Wattles repeatedly declared he had purchased the equity of redemption, and that his title to the property was then complete. Notwithstanding these declarations, it is very evident he did not consider the mortgage extinguished. Nicholas P. Randal testified, that after the sale he asked Wattles, why he let Sabin bid off the property for so small a sum? he answered that Sabin would be glad to give it up, as he had enough upon it to induce him to do so. Randal believes that the mortgage was mentioned as the incumbrance on the property. Whatever may have been the opinion of Wattles as to the then state of his title, it is apparent he did not consider the mortgage a mere caput mortuum, but a valid security.

On the 9th Nov.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.