Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1824 (Doe on Demise of Tate's Heirs v. Southard)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1824

Henderson, Judge.

Colour of title, as applicable to the present subject, is evidently the production of our own country. I will not, therefore, go abroad for an explanation; the name, I presume, was taken from what is called giving colour in pleading, which is never used in this State, and not often, I believe, in England. The word is not to be found in the act of 1715; it is first used in our act of 1791. Giving colour in pleading, is giving to your adversary a title

which is

defective, hut not so obviously so, that it would be apparent to one not skilled in the law, it must be such as would perplex a layman; it, therefore, draws the consideration of the question from the Jury, (the lay gents,) to the Court, which is the object of the pleading. I think we should

*121

go

no further than our act of 1715, at most not further than the act of 1791, on the question we are now investigating. The 2nd section of the act of 1715, ratifies and confirms all sales made by creditors, executors or administrators, husbands and their wives, husbands seised in right of their wives, or by indorsement of patents,

or otherwise,

where the possessor shall have been, in possession for seven years; The act of 1791, confirming possessions against the State, uses the same phraseology, except that the words

other colourable

title, are substituted for the words, “

or otherwise,”

used in the act of 1715. The words, “or otherwise,” and “ other colourable title,” mean title of the

like

kind. Those mentioned in the act are all written

ones;

are all such as, upon their face, profess to pass the title; in some of them, conveyance is

sufficient

to pass the title, but the

defect

lies in the want of title in the grantor $ in the last instance put, the indorsement of a patent, the conveyance is defective.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.