Supreme Court of the United States February 19, 1825 (Carneal v. Banks)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-02-1825
Mr. Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opinion of the Court.
These appeals are from a decree of the Circuit Court for the District of Kentucky, in which Carneal’s heirs were decreed to pay Henry Banks 2,500 dollars, for failing to perform a contract entered-into between Thomas Carneal, their ancestor, and the said Henry Banks.
The bill filed by Henry Banks, charges, that his agent, Cuthbert Banks, entered into R contract with Thomas Carneal, whereby he agreed to transfer to Carneal the right of the said Banks in 30,000 acres of land purchased by him from JohreHarvie, for which right said Carneal “ agrees to give a tract of 2,000 acres of land on Green river, patented for Philip Philips, which was sold out of a tract of 22,100 acres, by Philips, to Michael Lacassaign, deceased, by said Eacassaign to said Carneal, on the 30th of July, 1797, for which land said Carneal is to, make a general warranty deed whenever thereunto required.”
The bill further charges, that Carneal was guilty of fraud in pretending to have a good title
*183
to the said 2,000 acres of land, the whole being covered with better titles, and in representing the land as much more valuable than it really is. The bill prays, that the contract may be rescinded, and that the plaintiff may be reinstated in his rights to the said 30,000 acres of land or have the value thereof in damages. And that the heirs of John Harvie, deceased, in whom the legal title to the said 30,000 acres remains, may be decreed to convey the same to him.
The heirs of T Carneal deny all fraud in his representation of the value of the land sold to the plaintiff, and insist on their ability to convey the same. They admit, that the deed from Lacassaign to him was not recorded within the. time limited by law, one of the three subscribing witnesses then required for its proof, having did before it was offered to the Court.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit