New York Supreme Court August 15, 1826 (Andrews v. Kneeland)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1826

Curia, per

Savage, Ch. J.

The sale in this case was clearly a sale by sample. There could be no other, according to the weight of the testimony. That, however, is a question of fact.

It has been deliberately settled by this court, in the case of The Oneida Manuf. So. v. Lawrence, (4 Cowen, 440,) that in case of sale by sample, the vendor is responsible, that the bulk of the commodity shall be equal in quality to the sample.

It is only necessary to inquire whether the judge correctly charged the jury as to the power of the agent.

The difference between a general and a special agent is well understood. The principal is bound by the acts of a general agent, provided they are within the scope of his authority. But an agent constituted for a particular purpose, and under a limited and circumscribed power, cannot bind his principal by any act beyond his authority. (1 Liverm. 107-8.) Thus, in Batty v. Carswell, (2 John. 48,) the authority was limited to a single act, to be performed in a particular manner. The authority was to execute a note for $¡250, payable in six months. The agent gave a note payable in GOtlays. This court held the principal not bound. But where the agent is not limited as to the manner of doing a particular act, the principal may be bound by his acts, though exceeding the authority intended to be given to him. Thus, in the case of Fenn v. Harrison, (3 T. R. 757, 4 id. 177,) the fact at first ap*358peared to be, that the defendants had instructed their agent to get the bill discounted; but charged him not to indorse it. He, however, did indorse it; and though Lord Ken-2/on was inclined to hold the defendants responsible ; yet the rest of the court ruled otherwise ; and granted a new trial. Upon the next trial, it appeared that the defendants desired their special agent to get the bill discounted, without restricting his power to endorse.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.