Supreme Court of North Carolina July 5, 1827 (Wilkes v. . Clark)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-07-1827

Tanxor, Chief-Justice.

The question to be decided in this case is, whether the Superior Court erred in refusing to instruct the jury, that

Pugh

had such an interest in the corn, that he should have joined in the action brought by

Wilkes,

and that

Wilkes

alone could not maintain

it;

and my opinion on the case, and

Pugh's

deposition is, that there was no error committed by the Court in refusing this instruction.

The agreement made between the Plaintiff and

Pugh,

took place one or two months after the former had purchased the corn from

John Wilkes,

and it w as a part of that agreement, that, the Plaintiff was to receive and dispose of the corn, in his own name, in the same manner as if Pag/iiiad nothing to do with it. The agreement to this effect was private between them, and

Pugh

thinks

*182

it was unknown to any other person. It was consequent-iy unknown to

John Wilkes,

when lie shipped the corn, i 11 who must have believed that lie was acting as the agent of, and for the sole account of the Plaintiff

Henry Wilkes.

If therefore, when lie made the shipment, an express contract had.been made between him and the carrier,' it must have been made in the name of his. brother, and would have enured to his benefit; for the law will only imply that, which it may be supposed the parties would have expressed, had they defined the terms of the agreement.

It follows, that

John Wilkes

was the agent for the Plaintiff alone, and that the latter was unknown in the contract of shipment. The case then falls within the rule, that the party with whom the contract was made, may alone sustain the action, although it turn out that another person, whose name is not mentioned, is secretly interested. Thus in the case of

Lloyd

v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.