Supreme Court of Louisiana April 15, 1827 (Dicks v. Barton)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1827

Porter J.

delivered the opinion of the court. The record in this case, not being certified in such a manner, as to enable us to examine the cause on its merits, our attention is confined to the bills of exceptions.

The first, was taken to the judge's overruling several exceptions contained in the defendant’s answer.

One of these exceptions is, that the copy of the petition served on the defendant, did not correspond with the original. The particular variance is not set out. We have collated them, and can find no difference, except that in the document filed with the answer, the indorsements on the back of the note annexed to the petition, are not copied. Admitting, however, there are others, there is not evidence before us to enable us to say that the judge erred.—The sheriff’s return states, that he served a copy of the petition on the defendant.—There is no proof that the copy which the defendant has annexed to his answer, is that which was served on him; consequently, the *658sheriff’s return must be received as true. Code of Practice, no. 275.

The second exception is, that the petition did not contain an averment, that notice of the transfer, of the note sued on, to the plaintiff, was ever given to the defendant. There was no necessity for the petition containing such an averment, as, whether the defendant had notice of it, or not, he was responsible to the endorse.

The third exception, as it is called, went to the merits, and as the evidence does not come up, its correctness cannot be gone into here.

The second bill of exceptions is of a very novel kind. It states that, after the evidence was gone through, the defendant moved for judgment in his favor; and that, notwithstanding that motion, the court gave judgment the next morning for the plaintiff, without overruling the motion. This is gravely excepted to as illegal, unjust, and irregular.

It is extraordinary, that counsel should deem it their duty, to place such matter before this court, for its examination.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.