Supreme Court of Pennsylvania June 6, 1827 (Reigart v. M'Grath)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-06-1827
*67The opinion of the court was delivered by
Gibson, J.
It is not disputed that in respect to the power in question the legislature has put the clerk of the Mayor’s Court of this city, on a footing with the prothonotaries of the Common Pleas; and these have express power to administer the oath by the terms of the arbitration act. The question, then, is whether this power may be delegated; and the case of the Commonwealth v. Greason, goes far to determine that it may; The argument on the other side is, that the administration of the oath being on a judicial proceeding, is a judicial act; and that the case is different in this respect from the Commonwealth v. Greason, inasmuch as the provisions of the registry act involve no judicial proceeding whatever, and consequently that the duty of the clerk of the Quarter Sessions was purely ministerial. The true line of distinction, I apprehend, lies between those cases where authority to administer an oath is an accessary of judicial power residing in the officer; and those where it is conferred specifically by an immediate grant. In the first, the officer cannot delegate the principal: in the second, there' is neither principal nor accessary, nor any thing but a naked act directed to be done by a statute. Now what judicial power is there supposed to reside in the person of a prothonotary? The nominating of arbitrators involves the exercise of discretion, and may, therefore, be supposed to approach nearer to a judicial act than any other within the scope of his duties. Arbitrators when appointed are judges, but those who appoint them are not necessarily so. A power of appointment is of an executive not of a judicial nature, otherwise the governor, who appoints judges and all other officers, would be what he unquestionably is not, a judicial instead of an executive magistrate. It furnishes no reply that even he cannot delegate his powers. His office is a high public trust, for which he.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit