Supreme Court of New Jersey February 15, 1827 (State v. Woodward)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1827

The Chief Justice delivered the opinion of the court.

Robert Woodward came before this court in September, 1825, and having shewn that a-road had been laid out in *29part through his lands, and in part through the lands of other persons, and that the road as laid out and returned by the surveyors varied in certain parts from the petition of the applicants and the order of the court of common pleas, he obtained the allowance of a writ of certiorari. On the return of the writ, David Mairs and others, certain of the land owners, made an application to the court to quash the writ, and the arguments of the counsel of the parties wero heard at the last term.

Certain principles applicable to this subject are well settled. The allowance of a writ of certiorari in cases of this kind is in tho discretion of the court, who are discernere per legem quid sit justurn. Coxe 250, Penn. 1026, 1 South. 389. On the return of the writ, if such matters, other than those properly inquirable into by the writ, are shewn to the court, by a party whoso rights or interests are affected, as would if shewn at the moment of application, have induced the court to refuse the allowance, the writ will be quashed. This rule results from the fact that the allowance is made exparte and without notice. Thus, for example, want of jurisdiction to issue the writ may be shewn on a motion to quash; but the court would not, on such motion, sustain an attempt to shew that the reason assigned for the allowance, or that other reasons, if such there were, on which reliance was placed to annul the proceeding to be inquired of by the writ, were untrue in fact or ineffectual in law.

The way is then open to examine the truth and effect of the grounds exhibited by David Mairs for quashing this writ. These ^grounds are mainly supported as to [*23 matters of fact, by the affidavits of Apollo Mairs and Abraham Tilton. But it is objected that they are incompetent witnesses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.