Supreme Court of North Carolina June 5, 1828 (State v. . Mumford)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1828

*521

Tayuor, Chief-Justice.

The objection taken in arrest of judgment, is founded on the assumption, that the only materia! enquiry before the Justice was, whether

Noble

had assaulted

Mumford,

or not, on the day specified, and that whether he struck him on the back, or not, at the last wrestle, was irrelevant, and unconnected with that question ; that the. assignment of perjury in the circumstances, is consistent witli the belief that the. Defendant might have sworn truly as to the principal fact, viz. the* assault. This presents two questions — whether the materiality of the enquiry is sufficiently stated in the indictment, and whether the assignment of peijury is properly and distinctly made ?

It is laid down as a rule, which I find no where controverted, that it should appear on the face of the indictment, that the oath taken was material to the question depending, not by setting forth the circumstances which, render it so, in describing the proceedings of a former trial, but by a general allegation that the particular question became material. In

Jly.lett’s case,

a leading one on this subject, it is stated, that it became a material question on the hearing of the complaint, and the hearing of that is stated in general terms. (1

Term Rep.

66.) In the

King

v.

Dowlin,

the question was much debated. It is there stated, that the question became material on the trial, in the same general terms that it is stated, here; and the trial is referred to in, this manner, that “ at sucli a Court J. R. was in due form of law tried upon a certain indictment, then and títere depending against him for murder.”

Bowlin

was a w itness against J. R. on that trial, and the perjury was assigned, in his swearing, that “ he had never said he would be revenged of the said J. R. and would work his ruin.” On this part of the case, it was argued on behalf of

Bowlin,

that all those facts ought to be stated in the proceedings against J. R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.