Supreme Court of Virginia March 8, 1828 (Sawney v. Carter)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-03-1828
March 8.
JUDGE COADTER
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The pauper, in this case, claims his freedom on an alleged contract between his master and him, at the time he was purchased at an executor’s sale, that on paying his purchase money, he should be free. He alleges that he has paid accordingly ; but, that his master would not emancipate him. The proof of the contract is by no means clear; although, if that was proved, and such a contract could be enforced in Equity, there is perhaps proof enough in the record, of his master having received some property, to wit, a waggon and three horses, which the pauper claimed as his own, and the proceeds of his *653earnings by waggoning, to send the case to an account.
There is no case in this Court, that I can find, justifying the idea that a Court of Equity can enforce sucha contract; but, the reverse has been decided, as will be seen hereafter. There is no doubt that a Court of Equity may entertain a bill, where the party has been detained in ^slavery and has a legal title to his freedom, but there is some impediment to the assertion of that right at Law which would, in any other case, justify the interposition of a Court of Equity; as, if the Will, by which he was emancipated, was fraudulently suppressed, or destroyed; or a Deed, prior to that of emancipation, and which had been abandoned, was fraudulently set up as a bar to the recovery at Law; as was lately decided in the case of Talbert v. Jenny, ante, 159.
In the case of Dempsey v. Lawrence, Gilm. 333, the pauper was not so before the Court, as that the merits could be decided, either by the Court below, or by this Court. The bill was dismissed; and this Court only sent the case back, to be placed in a situation in, which it could be tried on the merits. How this Court would have decided, coulu me merits have been gone into, cannot therefore be known ; and consequently, that case can give no rule in this.
The case of John Rose, a pauper, v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit