Supreme Court of the United States February 27, 1829 (President of the Bank of the United States v. Weisiger)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-1829

Mr Justice JohnsqN

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case turns altogether upon doctrines peculiar to the states of Virginia and Kentucky. It is thb ease of a suit in equity, instituted by the indorsee, or, in the language of the country, the assignee, of a promissory note, to charge an intermediate'indorger. All the doctrine on the subject will be found fully stated in the two cases. of. Riddle' & Co.

vs.

Mándeville. <fc Jameison, reported among the decisions of this Court; and in the cases of Smallwood

vs.

Woods, and Spratt us. M’Kinney, to be found among the decisions of the court of appeals of Kentucky.

The defendant here has demurred to the bill, for. want of equity, and this raises the first question in the cause.

In the last case decided in this Court, between Riddle &. Co. cs. Mandeville & Jameison, which was a case in most respects similar to the present, this Court decided5 that a suit could be maintained

in equity

by the holder-pf an indorsed, note against a rémote indorser; and.upon grounds perfectly familiar to courts exercising:equity jurisdiction. It was a Virginia contract, governed by the same Jaw which is of force in Kentucky. This. Cojurt.had before,decided, that by . the laws of the country, governing thé contract, a suit at-law could not'be maintained between the holder of the note and a remote indorser. But’then a suit at law could have been maintained by him against the immediate indorser, and by him against the preceding indorser, and so on through any number of indorsers. This presented the ordinary case of an assignment of a chose in action, which transfers an interest without the right of action.

To maintain this demurrer then, it was incumbent on the defendant to have shown, that there, was some principle in the jurisprudence of Kentucky, that could sustain a distinc

*348

t ion'between his case and that previously decided here : twit every thing concurs to repel the idea of stich a distinction. In the case "of Drake

vs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.