Supreme Court of the United States January 29, 1830 (Gordon v. Ogden)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-1830

Mr C. J. Marshall

delivered the opinion of the Court.

A motion has been made to dismiss his writ of error because the court has no jurisdiction over it. The plaintiff below claimed more than two thousand dollars in his declaration, but obtained a judgment for a less sum. The defend-, ant below has sued put a writ of error, .and contends now that the matter in dispute is not determined by the judgment, but by the_sum claimed in the declaration.

This court has jurisdiction over final judgments and decrees.of the circuit court, where the matter in dispute exceeds the sum or value of two thousand dollars. The jurisdiction of the court has been supposed to depend on the sum or value of the matter in dispute in this court, not on that which was in dispute in the circuit court. If.the writ of error be brought by the plaintiff below, then the sum which his declaration shows to be U.Ue may be still recovered, should the judgment for a smaller sum be reversed and conseauently the whole sum claimed iá.still in dispute. But if the writ of error be brought by the defendant in the original action, the judgment 6f this fcourt'can only affirm that of the circuit court, and consequently the. matter in dispute-cannot exceed the amount of that judgment. Nothing- but that judgment is in dispute be-twee.n-the parties. The counsel for the plaintiff ift error relies on the case of Wilson

vs.

Daniel, 3 Dall. 401. That case,- it is admitted, is in pdfnf.-.-.It turns on the- principle that the jurisdiction of this court depénds on the sqm which was in dispute before the judgment was rendered in the circuit court. Although that case was decided-by a divided court, and although we-thjnk, that upon the true construction of the iwenty.-secon.d,section of the judicial act, the jurisdiction of the court-depends- upon thejs.um in dispute between the parties

ni

the case stands upon the-writ of error-,-wo should be much inclined to adhere to the decision in Wilson

vs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.