New York Supreme Court May 15, 1831 (Denning v. Roome)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1831
By the Court.
The defendant was an inhabitant of the city of New-Yorb, and an officer of the corporation, when he did the act which is charged in the declaration as a trespass. The plaintiff insists that the defendant acted as an agent of the corporation in committing the trespass, and that the court must consider him as defending in that character, and not in his individual capEtcity. If he acted as the agent of the corporation, it is said we are to regard that body as the parly, and to exclude their minutes as incompetent evidence to justify their own acts. What right has this court to select the character in which the defendant shall justify himself] If it be true in point of fact that he has a defence as a citizen, which he has not as the officer of the corporation, we cannot say he shall not stand before us in the former character. If, as one of the inhabitants of the city of NewYorb, the minutes of the corporation are admissible evidence in his favor, we cannot say he shall not use them for that purpose because he happens to hold an office under that body. Without recognizing the distinction adverted to, we proceed to consider the minutes, and proceedings of the corporation, as offered by the defendant in his defence, in his individual character. Were they admissible ]
The corporation of New-Yorb differs widely from a private corporation. It more nearly resembles the legislature of *656an independent state, acting under a constitution prescribing ¡tg p0Wer3i The acts of this corporation concern the rights of the inhabitants of the city ; it exercises a delegated power not for its own emolument, but for the interests of its constituents ; and while it keeps within the limits of its authority, the constituents are bound by the acts of the corporation. When the citizen wishes to shew those acts, he must resort to the authentic record of them, which is the original minutes of the corporation. These minutes, as the case states, were produced on the trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit