Supreme Court of Alabama June 15, 1833 (Cavanaugh v. Tatum)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1833
Saffold, J.
The revision of -the judgment of the county Court, on the certiorari, involve.-! the construction of the statutes of 1027 and 1020, respecting the liability of indorsers of notes, &c., for sums not exceeding fifty dollars.
Two points are relied on, by the plaintiff in error, for a reversal of. the judgment below—
1st. That the Court erred as stated in the bill of exceptions.
2d. That there was error in sustaining the plaintiff’s demurrer to defendant’s first plea.
Noticing the latter first, it is sufficient to say, it presents the question, whether if the holder of an indorsed note neglect or omit to use the diligence required by statue, to make the money out of the maker, before suing the indorsor, the latter can avail himself of this matter of defence by special plea in bar; and also, whether the matter pleaded, that the maker, at the time of indorsing the note, was a resident of the county, engaged in business, and was possessed of property more than sufficient to pay the debt, which remained subject to attachment, &e., constitute a legal ground of defence ?
The diligence required by statute was prescribed in lieu of the common law requisition of early demand of payment from the maker, and notice to the *209indorser, and also for the better protection of the latter. So far as the certainty of a declaration is required in the Circuit or County Courts, for the trial of appeals from the judgments of magistrates, the plaintiff must set forth a legal cause of action in his declaration or statement. To do this, before the statute, it was necessary, to charge an indorser, that the plaintiff should aver a demand and refusal: since the statute, it is equally necessary he should aver a compliance with the substituted requisition, and make proof thereof; else, he can not recover.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit