Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 24, 1834 (Tenney v. How)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-1834

Morton J.

delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an action on the case, founded on the sixth section of Si. 1830, c. 99. It is brought against the inspector-general of leather, by purchasers of leather, to recover damages in the nature of a penalty. The plaintiffs’ right to recover depends upon the construction of the statute. The words of the statute are, <£ that if any side or sides of sole leather shall vary when thoroughly dried, so as to weigh five per cent more or less than the weight marked thereon by any inspector, the inspector who inspected the same shall be subject to the payment of the whole variation, at a fair valuation, to be recovered by the party injured thereby.”

The plaintiffs proved that a quantity of leather purchased by them, and inspected by the defendant, actually weighed ten per cent less than it was marked. Upon this the plaintiffs claimed to recover for the deficiency, according to the fair value of the leather. But there was' no evidence that this leather was injured.

In defence it is contended, that the leather, when weighed by the plaintiffs, was not in a proper state to be weighed, but had been unreasonably dried. And the defendant offered to show that leather in a proper state to be sold and to be weighed and marked, will, when exposed to the sun and air in the manner the plaintiffs’ was, shrink more than ten per cent. Does this amount to a legal defence to the action ?

The statute doubtless was made principally for the protec tion of purchasers. And was intended to save them from imposition in false weights and in the sale of leather insufficiently dried. We have met with not a little difficulty in ascertaining the true meaning of the clause under consideration. This has arisen in part from the phraseology of the statute, and in part from a difficulty inherent in the subject matter.

We have examined the whole statute with care.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.