U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania May 15, 1835 (United States v. Halberstadt)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1835

BALDWIN, Circuit Justice.

The case in the district court was an action brought by the United States to recover from the defendant a penalty of one hundred dollars for removing an empty cask which had contained imported spirits, before the marks and numbers which had been put thereon, pursuant to the provisions of the collection act of 1799. had been defaced as directed by the 44th section thereof. The case was submitted to a .iury. who found a special verdict “that the defendant did remove the cask described in the declaration, without having the marks erased therefrom, and had purchased the same from persons unknown to the jury,” on which judgment was rendered for the defendant. [Case No. 15,-277.]

The only question made at the bar is whether the penalty prescribed attaches to the purchaser of such empty cask. The 44th section of the law provides that on the sale of any empty cask which had contained imported spirits, and before the delivery to the purchaser, or any removal thereof, the marks and numbers which shall have been set thereon shall be defaced and obliterated in presence of an officer of the customs, at which time the certificate which ought to aecom-pany such cask shall be returned and'can-celled. These are the directory parts of the law. prescribing what shall be done. The clause which inflicts the penalty is: “And every person who shall obliterate, couuter--feit. alter, or deface, any mark or number, placed by an officer of inspection upon any cask containing spirits, or any certificate thereof. Or who shall sell, or in any way alienate, or remove any cask which has been emptied before the marks and numbers have been so defaced in presence of an officer, or who shall neglect or refuse to deliver the certificate issued to accompany the cask, of which the marks and numbers shall have been defaced on being required by an officer of inspection of the customs, shall forfeit one hundred dollars.” 3 [Bior. & D.] Laws, 177 [1 Stat. 660].

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.