Supreme Judicial Court of Maine May 15, 1836 (Greenlaw v. Greenlaw)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1836

The opinion of the Court, after a continuance, nisi, was drawn up by

Weston C. J.

The demandant in his opening had shewn title, by introducing a deed to himself of the demanded premises from Israel Cox. The tenant then adduced in evidence a deed, subsequently made by the demandant, of the same premises to Thomas C. Greenlaw, under whom the husband of the tenant claimed. An attempt was made to show that deed inoperative. Its validity and effect was open to inquiry; and it was competent for the demandant to show, if he could, that nothing passed by that instrument. It was repelling proof, to which he had a right to resort. If he failed upon this ground, there was nothing to prevent his availing himself of any condition in that deed, or of any defeasance executed at the same time, or of any recon-veyance made to him, either absolute or conditional. An unsuccessful attempt to defeat a deed, to which he was a party, did not subject him to a forfeiture or waiver of any interest, to which he was legally entitled in the land in controversy. We are aware of no principle of law, which forbids his submitting both grounds at the same time to the jury: that if the first failed him, he might have the benefit of the second. And we are of opinion that the Court below rightfully permitted this course.

The mortgage deed, executed by the husband of the tenant, was substituted for one having the same conditions, previously executed by Thomas C. Greenlaw; and that was in consideration of the conveyance of the same land to him, which was previously the demandant’s sole property. Both mortgages secured a benefit to his wife. Her interest, being purchased with his property, might have been defeated by his creditors. The principal contract, collaterally secured by the mortgage, was to support the demandant and his wife for their lives, and the life of the survivor. This contract procured by the husband, and for a consideration moving from him, he might release or discharge.

*186In Draper v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.