Supreme Court of Pennsylvania October 15, 1836 (Hays v. Shannon)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1836

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Gibson, C. J.

An unavoidable consequence of treating lands as chattels for payment of debts, is our practice to treat the executor or administrator of a debtor as the legal party to answer process against the real assets, whether scire facias or' original. Its defect is that the heir, though admitted to defend spontaneously, is not joined as a party on the record, nor is a day in court always given him by notice. It is, however, indispensable to bring in the personal representative in order to protect the interests of the other creditors; and it is conceded that, for want of this, the judgment in this instance was erroneous. But was it void; or rather, did it, in the words of the statute, “ warrant the awarding of the execution?” It is decisive that a scire facias is a substitute in practice here, for an action of debt elsewhere; and that the judgment on it is quod recuperet, instead of a bare award of execution. How it became so, it is bootless to inquire. From the foundation of the province to the present time, common law principles have been merged in our ignorance of common law forms, their best preservers and most conspicuous in-dices. Of this practice, we have a striking instance in the customary scire facias of the common pleas on a recognizance in the orphans’ court, which, as a process of execution, ought, by the 13 Ed. 3, c. 45, to be in the court where the judgment or recognizance is, because no other is competent to award the execution of which it is the initiative. We sometimes use it, and, questionless, as original process, where there is no debt of record at all; as in the case of a mortgage or a mechanic’s lien, which, though sufficient for notice to purchasers, ascertains nothing judicially in respect to the existence or amount of the debt. That remains to be done by 'verdict and judgment of recovery; and to that end, the scire facias is an original, writ to bring the parties before the court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.