Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 31, 1836 (M'Fadden v. Erwin)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1836

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Kennedy, J.

The rejection of the evidence, offered by the defendant below in support of his claim against the plaintiff there, as a set-off to the demand of the latter, is attempted to be supported upon two grounds First, Because it was, as is alleged, a claim for unliquidated damages: and second, Because it was a claim growing out of a partnership entered into between the plaintiff and the defendant for excavating a section of a certain canal.

In regard to the first ground, it is certainly a misapprehension of the true character of the demand, which the defendant below offered to prove against the plaintiff, to consider it a claim of unliquidated damages, or as being, from its nature, so uncertain as to be incapable of being reduced to certainty, and therefore not such as may be set up by the defendant under our defalcation act as a defence, either in whole or in part, to the plaintiff’s demand. Damages claimed for a breach of contract by one party against the other, on account of having done an act contrary to his agreement, or for not having performed an act, which by his agreement he was bound to do, may be deemed unliquidated in this sense, when the injury done or suffered is of such a nature as to furnish no fixed or certain rule for the measure of the damages thereby sustained: but surely this cannot be said of the defendant’s claim here, which was for money paid, laid out and expended by him, as he alleges, for the use of the plaintiff, who according to the agreement between them, was bound to' reimburse him. The measure of the damages or the amount, which the defendant would have a right to recover in such case, is perfectly certain and well settled.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.