Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court October 26, 1836 (Richardson v. Whiting)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-10-1836
Putnam J.
afterward drew up the opinion of the Court. We understand from the answer of the party summoned as trustee, that the master has no claim against the owners for his services, or otherwise, and that the owners themselves have demanded and claim to receive the money due from the freighters.
*531The plaintiffs rest their cause on the case of Lewis v. Hancock, 11 Mass. R. 72. In that case the consignees had paid the freight to the agent of the owners, taking their contract of indemnity to repay, if it should appear that they could not legally receive it. The plaintiff’s counsel contended, that me master had a lien upon the freight, for his own and mariners’ wages, and for repairs. The Court held, that the owners should repay the money. But the case does not state the amount of the master’s claim, nor in what it consisted. The opinion proceeds, we think, upon the assumption, that the payment to the owners was in violation of some rights or lien of the master in or upon the money. C. J. Sewall said : “ He (the master) may be understood, as against the owner himself, to have the same right in the freight money, which a factor or consignee has in the goods of the principal or consignor, for whom money has been advanced, or any liabilities incurred in consequence of the employment or consignment.” Be it so, for the sake of the argument. But suppose the factor has been paid for all his services and advancements, what right has he, more than a stranger, to withhold the property of the principal ? The case cited surely does not decide that he would have any. If one should purchase goods of a factor, and the principal should demand the money himself, and give notice to the purchaser not to pay to the factor, at the same time informing him that the factor had no lien upon the property, the buyer would not be justified in paying the factor, unless he could prove that the factor had a lawful lien upon the property to the extent of the sum so paid.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit