Supreme Court of Vermont January 15, 1836 (Bigelow v. Huntley)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1836

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Phelps, J.

-The sale of the horses by Bigelow to Gray was conditional. This being the case, the general property never passed. These sales are frequent, and it has always been considered that payment of the stipulated price was a condition precedent.

It is argued that such a sale is fraudulent in its effect. But we believe no case can be found, in which a mere conditional sale of thi s character has been held fraudulent in itself. The possession is consistent with the contract. And where there is no deception, the;re is nothing to sustain the suggestion of fraud. False repre-secitations may indeed be made, and where this is the case, the usnal consequences of fraud follow. But the mere circumstance that the vendee is'entrusted conditionally with the goods, and appears as owner, is not sufficient to divest the vendor of his property.

It appears in this case, that Gray called the horses his, with the kr íowledge of the plaintiff; but this does not appear to have been done, under such circumstances, as required of the plaintiff to disclose their real situation.

The more serious question involved in this case, arises out of i the technical objection, that the plaintiff having parted with his 'right of possession, for a limited period, which-had not expired, at the time of the supposed conversion, cannot sustain the action. Upon this point we are not unanimous. Yet there are two different points of view in which the case may be regarded, which have satisfied a majority of the court that the plaintiff is entitled tó re-' '■Cover.

First. We regard the payment of the stipulated price, as a condition ¿precedent. The general property in the horses, therefore, remained in the plaintiff. By virtue QÍ the attachment at the suit of Brown, And the eoasémjent proceeding, the right of possesion also vested in him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.