Supreme Court of Connecticut July 15, 1836 (Middletown Savings Bank v. Bates)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-07-1836
Bissell, J.
This motion has been supported on two grounds. The first is, that the judge on the circuit admitted Henry Carrington and Augustus Cook, Esquires, to testify in the cause.
It is claimed, that they were incompetent witnesses. From their examination, it appears, that they were trustees of the Savings Bank; but that they were neither stock-holders nor depositors. Nor had they any interest in the event of the suit, unless the fact of their being trustees created such an interest. Now, it is impossible to conceive how that circumstance should create any interest whatever. The charter, under which they derive their appointment, requires, that they shall manage this fund, for the benefit of others, and expressly forbids that they shall receive any compensation for their services. They, then, are trustees merely. They are not parties to the record : nor have they any imaginable interest in the fund, which is to be affected by the termination of this action. And it is, surely, too late, now to agitate the question, whether a mere trustee, without an interest, is a competent witness. The point has been too often decided. Comstock v. Hadlyme, 8 Conn. Rep. 254, Sears v. Dillingham, 12 Mass. Rep. 360.
The other question in the case arises out of the charge to the jury.
The action was brought by mortgagees against the mortgagor. And in regard to that portion of the mortgaged premises, now in controversy, it was admitted, that they were in possession of tenants of the defendant, in virtue of leases given subsequently to the mortgage ; and that he was in the reception of the rents and profits. Upon this state of facts, the jury were instructed, that they might find a disseisin by the defendant, and of course, a verdict in favour of the plaintiffs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit