Supreme Court of Virginia March 15, 1836 (Claiborne v. Gross)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1836

Carr, J.

Two judgments at law having been obtained by different persons against Gross, were transferred, one to Claiborne, and the other to Wimbish; and they filed separate bills against Gross, to set aside, as fraudulent, a deed made by him conveying his land to his daughters. After these bills had been separately ‘ answered, and had been depending for some time, the chancellor ordered, that they be united and proceeded in as one cause. Knowing that these consolidation orders were sometimes made in the courts of common law, it did not strike me to inquire whether they were proper in chancery also, until my attention was turned *339to the question by my brother Brooke, and some cases referred to. On examining these, I find the attempt to introduce such a practice into the court of chancery in England, has been discouraged. And as this is the first time the question has come before us, it may not be amiss to quote a passage from the latest case I find in the english books, in which the vice chancellor reviews the different eases on the subject. It is the case of the Warden and Fellows of Manchester College v. Isherwood, decided in 1829. 2 Sim. 476. 2 Cond. Eng. Ca. in Ch. 506. where the vice chancellor says—“ The general rule is, that every plaintiff1 shall be at liberty to conduct each suit that he institutes, in what way he thinks best. At lav/ there is one exception; in the case of policies of assurance : and the question is, whether in courts of equity any such exception has been allowed ? In the case of Pyke v. Brock, 3 Gwiil. 1345. in the year 1791, a motion was made to consolidate seven tithe suits. In that case, chief baron Eyre speaks of the practice as if it were common; but the reason assigned for making the order was, that no cause was shewn. In Keighly v. Brown, 16 Ves. 344. in 1809, a motion was made, before answer, to consolidate tithe suits.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.