Supreme Court of Virginia August 15, 1836 (M'Farland v. Hunter)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1836

Carr, J.

The only point of importance in this cause arises upon exceptions taken to the opinion of the court declaring that the answers of the plaintiff to the interrogatories of the defendant, so far as they were responsive, were conclusive evidence, not to be contradicted or disproved by any evidence parol or written. This proceeding is under the 68th section of the late judiciary act, by which a plaintiff or defendant, in any action at law, wishing a discovery from the adverse party, to be used as evidence at the trial, is authorized to file written interrogatories to such party, and call upon him to answer the same in solemn form, on his oath or affirmation; and the law further declares, that the answers to such interrogatories shall be evidence at the trial of the cause, in the same manner, and to the same purpose and extent, and upon the same conditions in all respects, as if they had been procured upon a bill in chancery for discovery, but no further or otherwise. This question is of the first impression, and of great importance; and therefore, as the necessary books were not to be had at Lewisburg, the court took time to consider and investigate the subject. The object of the legislature seems clear. They meant to give to either party in a suit at law, the benefit of a discovery from the other, without the expense and delay of *492a regular suit in chancery. To ascertain the amount of this benefit, we must look to the nature of the bill of discovery, and the weight which is given to the disclosures made by the defendant to such bill. Mitford, p. 52. says, “Every bill is in reality a bill of discovery; but the species of bill usually distinguished by that title, is a bill for discovery of facts resting in the knowledge of the defendant, or of deeds or writings or other things in his custody or power, and seeking no relief in consequence of the discovery.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.