Supreme Court of Louisiana June 15, 1836 (Fletcher's Heirs v. Cavelier)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1836

Bullard, J.,

delivered the opinion of the

At the August term, 1832, judgment favor of the plaintiffs, for three undivided fou in controversy, but the case was remanded to ascertain the value of the improvements, &c. and it was ordered that no execution should issue for the plaintiffs until they shall have paid the value of the improvements. 4 Louisiana Reports, 266.

On these questions of the value of the improvements and fruits, a jury having pronounced on the second trial and judgment being rendered accordingly, the plaintiffs again appealed after soliciting in vain a new trial in the court below.

A careful examination of the evidence has failed to convince us that the complaints of the appellants are well founded, as to the amounts found by the jury.

The obligations of the war-rantor depend on the law in force at the time of the sale. According to the provisions of the Civil Code, 354, article 57, the seller is bound on the eviction of his vendee, to pay the augmented value of the property, above the price of the sale.

The original price added, to the " rents and profits, does not necessarily constitute the measure by which the liability of the warrantor is to be tested.

The warrantor is not to be called on to reimburse, until the judgment of eviction has had its effect against theparty evicted.

But, it is urged, that the court erred in decreeing that an execution might issue against the plaintiffs, if ■within sixty-days the estimated value of the improvements was not paid by them. The argument of the appellants on this point, rests on the hypothesis that the plaintiffs are entitled at once to all the rights and actions of a joint owner, as soon as the question of title to an undivided part was determined in their favor, and that they could require a sale of the whole tract of land and an adjustment of the improvements and fruits as incidental to that proceeding.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.